The National Scene - Written by Beasley Allen on Thursday, September 15, 2011 8:25 - 0 Comments
According to a lawsuit, filed in federal court in Atlanta by a doctor and a nurse, one of the nation’s largest providers of kidney dialysis deliberately wasted medicine in order to secure hundreds of millions of dollars in extra payments from Medicare. The whistle-blower lawsuit says that the company, DaVita, used larger than necessary vials of medicine knowing that Medicare would pay for the unused portion of each vial if it were deemed unavoidable waste. As expected, DaVita, which treats nearly a third of the nation’s dialysis patients, has denied the accusations.
The accusations are the latest involving how financial incentives have driven overuse of pharmaceuticals in the dialysis business. At least, that surely seems to be the case. In January, Medicare began a payment system that pays for the overall treatment which means it doesn’t pay separately for the drugs used. Interestingly, many practices, including the size of some vials used, suddenly changed. This provided an instant case study of how financial incentives can influence treatment choices.
Medicare, which pays for most dialysis treatments, used to reimburse clinics separately for the drugs they used. Clinics could make a profit because Medicare would pay more than the clinics paid to buy the drugs. In January, to deter overuse of drugs, Medicare instituted a new system in which it pays a fixed amount per treatment, including most of the drugs used. It’s pretty simple – if the clinic can treat the patient for less than the amount paid by Medicare, it makes money. But if it can’t, then the clinic loses money. This so-called “bundled payment system” has instantly turned drugs from a source of profit to a cost to be avoided. As a result, it appears the dialysis clinics have responded to the new system, but not in a good way.
One of the men who filed the lawsuit, Daniel D. Barbir, was a nurse who served from 2000 to 2006 as director of a dialysis clinic in Cumming, Ga. The clinic was owned by Gambro, a major dialysis chain acquired by DaVita in 2005. Mr. Barbir resigned in 2006 after complaining about the clinic’s practices. Dr. Alon J. Vainer, a nephrologist who was a medical director at various Gambro and DaVita clinics in Georgia, is the other Plaintiff. Dr. Vainer’s positions were not renewed after it was learned that he had filed the lawsuit.
Source: The Atlanta Journal Constitution
Leave a Reply
- Testosterone Multidistrict Litigation Has Been Formed
- Exploding Airbags is the Next Hidden Danger Lurking on the Horizon
- Favorite Bible Verses
- An Update on the Firm's Mass Torts Litigation
- The Civil Justice System Does Make a Difference
- BP's Stay Request Fails Before the Supreme Court
- Eight Car Makers Join in the Recall of Exploding Airbags
- The Deepwater Horizon Claims Program is Up and Running Again
- Favorite Bible Verses
- J&J Pays Oregon $4 Million To Settle Hip Implant Marketing Claims
- EPA Should Update Fracking Pollution Regulations
- Deepwater Fracking Raises Environmental Concerns
- $27.8 Million Settlement Finalized In TVA Coal Ash Spill
- Illinois Transport Company Settles Fatal Crash Suit For $2.7 Million
- Settlement For Family Of College Student Killed In Crash After Alabama National Championship Game
- Macy’s Fined $1 Million For Decapitation Of Warehouse Employee
- Texas Plastics Plant Fined $174,000 For Safety And Health Violations
- OSHA Says Safety Violation Continue At Oklahoma Oil Refinery
- Company Cited In Fatal West Virginia Cell Tower Collapse
- New Safety Directive Issued By OSHA On Communication Tower Work
- $27 Million Verdict Returned In Texas Against McDonald’s
- Was just wondering if you can still be in this lawsuit. I was a manager for 8 yr...
- I keep reading that the pratice of steering is illegal and whole-heartidly suppo...
- Hello William, thank you for your question. We are not aware of any pending liti...
- Has litigation commenced as a result of this recall?...
- Sorry I meant to say settlement papers, but I did speak to someone in the Lawyer...
- I just spoke to someone and was told it will be another month or two before I wi...
- 2005 F150 super cab. Driver side regulator just broke. Dealer wants $200 just fo...
- Today, the 4th window failed in my 2004 F-150 SuperCrew - I bought it new and th...
Recent Settlements - Feb 9, 2012 7:09 - 0 Comments
More In Recent Settlements
- A Further Update On The AWP Litigation
- Firm Reaches Settlement In Fort McClellan Radio Tower Collapse Case
- Firm Reaches Settlement In Sikorsky Helicopter Crash
- The Philadelphia Story
- St. Croix, Virgin Islands Settlement
Product Liability - Sep 4, 2014 13:13 - 0 Comments
More In Product Liability
- More Problems With Goodyear RV Tires
- NHTSA Offers Online Vehicle Recall Check
- Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against Mazda For Engine Valve Defect
- GM Sued For Alleged Antifreeze Defect In Chevy Cruze Models
- Settlement By Kia And Hyundai In Fuel Efficiency MDL Is Approved
Recalls Update - Sep 4, 2014 11:03 - 0 Comments
More In Recalls Update
- USDA Recalls 7.5 Tons Of Applegate Frozen Chicken Nuggets
- J&J Unit Recalls Hysterectomy Device Over Cancer Fears
- Samson International Recalls Bar Stool Due To Fall Hazard
- Bexco Recalls Franklin & Ben Mason 4-in-1 Convertible Cribs Due To Fall And Entrapment Hazards
- Ace Bayou Bean Bag Chairs Recalled Because Of Suffocation And Choking Hazards