Business Litigation, Fraud, Securities Litigation, The Corporate World - Wednesday, May 1, 2013 16:45 - 0 Comments
District Judge Victor Marrero in Manhattan has signed off on a $602 million insider-trading settlement between a unit of SAC Capital Advisors and U.S. securities regulators. But the judge said final approval rests on the outcome of another high-profile case now on appeal. Judge Marrero called the settlement amount “significant and proportional to the sums allegedly at issue.” However, the judge conditioned his approval on the impending ruling by a federal appeals court in the case we have discussed involving Citigroup Inc. In that case, a judge rejected Citigroup’s $285 million settlement with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) over the bank’s mortgage-linked securities dealings, taking issue with the agency’s longstanding policy of allowing defendants to neither admit nor deny allegations as part of a settlement.
Like the Citigroup case, the SAC settlement did not require the hedge fund run by money manager Steven A. Cohen to admit or deny the regulator’s insider-trading allegations. The settlement would resolve SEC civil charges against SAC subsidiary CR Intrinsic. Judge Marrero wrote in a 34-page opinion that it was “incongruous” for the hedge fund to admit no wrongdoing while agreeing to such a high settlement when it would cost “a fraction of that amount,” about $1 million, to litigate.
The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals is expected to soon issue an opinion in the Citigroup case. The appeal stems from the 2011 rejection of the bank’s settlement with the SEC by Judge Marrero’s colleague, U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff. In that case Judge Rakoff has contended that public interest is not served by settlements in which there is no admission of what happened. I tend to agree with his assessment. But others say that such settlements can often be the only way to get companies to settle fraud cases. That, in my opinion, is a lame excuse.
The CR Intrinsic case relates to the conduct of former portfolio manager Mathew Martoma, who was criminally charged late last year with insider trading in two drug stocks, Elan Corp Plc and Wyeth (now owned by Pfizer Inc.). Another federal judge has already approved a $14 million settlement between the SEC and another SAC Capital unit, Sigma Capital Management.
Judge Marrero wrote that his approval of the CR Intrinsic pact would be final if the appeals court determines that district courts lack the authority to reject such settlements on the basis of reservations about these “neither admit nor deny provisions.” But the judge made it very clear that he would have serious reservations about such deals if the appeals court left him room to do so. He wrote:
Instances can and do arise in which courts should properly raise the level of scrutiny they accord to particular settlement agreements in particular situations.
The hedge fund, based in Stamford, Conn., previously has called the agreements “a substantial step” toward resolving all outstanding regulatory matters. The case is SEC v. CR Intrinsic Investors, which is in the U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York.
Source: Yahoo News
- Federal Appeals Court Rules Against Pfizer In 3 RICO Suits
- Merrill Lynch Settles Overtime Lawsuit
- Class Action Status Granted In AIG Lawsuit
- Nintendo Found Guilty Of 3D Patent Infringement
- St. Louis Company Wins Suit Over Bowl-Shaped Chip
- Supreme Court Rules For Nike In Trademark Case
- AIG Sues Bank Of America And Others Over Mortgage Debt
- TiVo Settles Lawsuit Against Verizon For $250.4 Million
- BPI Sues ABC News For Defamation
- AllState Sues Florida Neurologic Clinic For $7.6 Million In False Claims
- Ford Sued Over F-150 Fuel Injection System
- Federal Court Jury Rules In Apple’s Favor
- Monsanto Wins Patent Suit Against DuPont In Genetically Modified Seed Case
- Spyker Sues General Motors for $3 Billion
- Apple Pays $60 Million To Settle China iPad Trademark Dispute
- Apple Claims $2.5 Billion Damages In Samsung Patent Case
- $147.2 Million Verdict In Wireless Patent Lawsuit
- Facebook And Yahoo Settle Lawsuits
- Pfizer Sued By Retailers For Generic Lipitor Delay
- Jere Beasley Report, April 2013
- Alabama to Receive $1,039,078 in Multi-State Settlement
- COSTCO Recalls Gold Coast Crab Dip
- Major Banks Assist In Payday Loans Banned By States
- Marc McHenry Hired As Investigator
- We Have Allowed A Culture Of Violence To Be Created In The U.S.
- Parting Words
- Closing Observations
- Favorite Bible Verses
- WSFA News Defenders Interviews
- Beasley Allen Hosts The Child Safety Helmet Giveaway
- SPLC Looks At How Payday And Title Loans Prey On Alabama’s Poorest
- Employee Spotlights
- Natura Pet Expands Recall Of Dry Pet Foods
- Winn-Dixie Recalls Organic Apple Juice On Mold Fears
- Manda Packing Recalling 468,000 Pounds Of Meat
- Carter’s Recalls Infant Clothings With Zippers Due To Choking Hazard
- I want to be involved in this lawsuit. I was a 3rd key making $8.25 per hour wi...
- Great to find a site like this that informs us of what our tax dollars are payin...
- can you please emaik me a copy of your article on april 16th wells fargo suid f...
- ALL OF THESE STORIES ARE SIMILAR AND ALMOAT THE SAME IN TIME FRAMES. FOR TWO YEA...
- they tried forexloaing on my home with a fraudulent note. how do I know that? I ...
- Yes, Sharon, we were aware of the button... however, it didn't work. Took it to...
- When would we get paid?...
- Would like to know how much longer will it be before we get paid....